Companies are often fixated on one goal: beating the competition. The traditional view of strategy frames business as a zero-sum game — if you win, your competitors must lose. But as industries evolve and disruption becomes the norm, this adversarial mindset is becoming outdated. The most successful companies aren’t just focused on defeating their rivals. Instead, they’re focused on creating more value for everyone in their ecosystem.
Enter the Value Net model — a new way of thinking about competition introduced by Adam Brandenburger and Barry Nalebuff. The Value Net challenges companies to look beyond their direct competitors and focus on the broader network of relationships that shape their success: suppliers, customers, substitutors, and complementors. It’s a shift from “me versus you” to “we grow together” — and it’s transforming how companies think about competitive strategy in the modern era.
What Is the Value Net Model?
At its core, the Value Net model is built on the idea that companies operate within interconnected ecosystems, and their success depends on managing four key relationships:
- Suppliers — those who provide the resources you need to operate.
- Customers — the people or businesses who buy your products or services.
- Substitutors — companies that offer alternative solutions to what you provide.
- Complementors — companies whose products or services enhance the value of your offering.
Unlike traditional models that focus solely on competition, the Value Net emphasizes that cooperation and collaboration can be just as important. The key question is: How can you optimize these relationships to create more value for yourself and your partners?
Breaking Down the Four Players in the Value Net
Let’s take a closer look at each player in the Value Net and how businesses can leverage these relationships to drive growth and competitive advantage.
1. Suppliers: More Than Just Cost Control
Traditional strategy views suppliers as a cost to be minimized. But in the Value Net framework, suppliers are key partners in creating value. Companies that build strong supplier relationships can unlock greater efficiency, innovation, and resilience in their supply chains.
For example, Apple’s relationship with its suppliers is a cornerstone of its success. Rather than treating suppliers as interchangeable vendors, Apple invests heavily in long-term partnerships with key component manufacturers. This allows Apple to secure exclusive access to cutting-edge technologies, maintain quality control, and optimize production costs.
The lesson? Suppliers are not just a source of costs — they’re a source of competitive advantage. By fostering mutually beneficial relationships, companies can create more stable and innovative supply chains that drive long-term success.
2. Customers: Moving from Transactions to Loyalty
In any business model, customers are central to value creation. But the Value Net framework challenges companies to think beyond one-time transactions and focus on building long-term customer relationships that create sustainable value.
Consider Amazon’s customer-centric approach. From the very beginning, Amazon has focused relentlessly on delivering value to customers through lower prices, faster shipping, and a seamless shopping experience. But Amazon’s strategy goes further: The company leverages its customer relationships to create complementary services, such as Prime memberships, AWS cloud services, and Alexa-enabled smart devices, that enhance customer loyalty and lock customers into its ecosystem.
The result? Amazon doesn’t just serve customers — it becomes indispensable to them. This long-term focus on value creation has helped Amazon achieve unprecedented customer loyalty, making it one of the most valuable companies in the world.
3. Substitutors: Your Hidden Threat (and Opportunity)
Substitutors are companies that offer alternative solutions to what you provide. Traditional strategy views substitutors as a threat — and rightly so. Substitutes can reduce demand for your product and erode your market share. But the Value Net model encourages companies to proactively manage the risk of substitution and, in some cases, turn threats into opportunities.
A great example comes from the retail industry. As e-commerce giants like Amazon and Alibaba grew, many traditional retailers saw them as a direct threat. But forward-thinking retailers like Walmart recognized that e-commerce was not just a threat — it was the future of retail. By investing heavily in digital transformation, Walmart was able to compete head-on with online platforms while maintaining its leadership in physical retail.
The key takeaway? Ignore substitutors at your own peril. Companies that anticipate substitution risks and adapt their strategies will be better positioned to navigate market disruptions.
4. Complementors: The Secret to Unlocking New Markets
Complementors are companies that enhance the value of your offering. Think of how apps enhance the value of smartphones, or how content creators drive engagement on social media platforms. The Value Net model highlights that building strong relationships with complementors can unlock new markets and revenue streams.
Consider Microsoft’s strategy with its Azure cloud platform. Rather than trying to do everything in-house, Microsoft has built a vast network of complementors, including software developers, system integrators, and independent vendors, who offer value-added services on top of Azure. This has allowed Microsoft to create a thriving ecosystem that benefits both the company and its partners.
The takeaway? Invest in complementors to expand your reach and increase your product’s value. In a world where ecosystems often outperform standalone businesses, complementors can be a key driver of growth.
Practical Applications of the Value Net Model
The Value Net framework isn’t just a theoretical concept. It has real-world applications across industries, particularly in markets undergoing disruption.
Here’s how companies can apply the Value Net to navigate change and create long-term value:
- Traditional retailers can partner with digital platforms (complementors) to enhance their online presence and customer experience, while proactively managing the threat of online substitutors.
- Pharmaceutical companies can collaborate with suppliers and research institutions to reduce R&D costs and accelerate drug development timelines.
- Tech companies like Apple and Google have built ecosystems of complementors — from app developers to hardware manufacturers — that drive customer engagement and lock-in.
In each case, companies that focus on creating value across their ecosystem are better equipped to adapt to disruption and maintain a competitive edge.
The Future of Competitive Strategy: Think Beyond Rivalry
The Value Net model challenges the traditional notion that business is a winner-takes-all game. In today’s interconnected world, the most successful companies are those that optimize their relationships across the entire ecosystem — not just with competitors, but with suppliers, customers, substitutors, and complementors.
This shift in mindset — from “beating the competition” to “growing the pie” — is reshaping industries like retail, healthcare, and technology. Companies that embrace the Value Net will be the ones driving the next wave of innovation and growth.
Because in the end, success in business isn’t just about competing harder. It’s about collaborating smarter.
Casey Ma is an MBA and MPH student at Yale University, specializing in Healthcare Management. With a background in strategy consulting, marketing, and project management, her passion lies at the intersection of healthcare transformation and strategic problem-solving. She is an advocate for collaborative innovation and enjoys engaging with professionals who share her enthusiasm for the healthcare and marketing sectors.
Image: DALL-E
🔴 Like this article?
Sharpen your edge in consulting